So basically for the last year and a half I have seen many people sharing their opinions on Colts GM Ryan Grigson. Some like what he has done while others have questioned the moves that he has made, sans the 2012 draft of course. I’m going to preface this by saying that I do not agree with all of the signings and trades Grigson has made in his tenure as general manager. However, I’m not in the majority that think Grigson has done a terrible job, nor am I in the minority that think he has done amazing. I’m in the middle. Basically, I’m Switzerland right now.
I’m about to break down the players he signed over the time during his tenure here and compare them with who was best available at that particular position during the same free agency period. There are going to be some of you that say Grigson should have signed this guy or that guy. I want to pair up who he did sign with who he could have signed. That way we can see if he did the right thing or not. As far as the NFL draft, I cannot go back and breakdown the drafts that he has done. Just like free agency, the NFL is a bigger crapshoot. There are a ton of top tier talents that are busts once they get to the NFL. So here we go. This should be fun…
Let’s start with the 2012 Free Agent Class.
Colts Signed or Traded For: Who Else Was Available:
Cory Redding Cliff Avril, Mario Williams, Red Bryant
Winston Justice Jared Gaither, Levi Brown
Tom Zbikowski Brandon Meriweather, James Ihedigbo
Mike McGlynn Jake Scott, Evan Mathis, Leonard Davis
Samson Satele Jeff Saturday, Dan Connolly
Brandon McKinney Aubrayo Franklin, Pat Simms
So looking at his first signings in his first year as a general manager comes with mixed feelings. Redding and Zbikowski were both obviously signings that Pagano wanted to see. He was installing a new defensive scheme and these guys already had a grasp on the system. We all know that Zbikowski didn’t pan out as well as people had hoped. Had they signed Brandon Meriweather the team would probably still be set at the SS position. Redding has progressed each season with the Colts but is aging and possibly signing Red Bryant would have been a better move.
The signings of Mike McGlynn and Samson Satele were head scratchers for sure. McGlynn was a former Eagle, where Grigson was a scout, so bringing in someone he knew was probably the reason for the signing. However with guys like Evan Mathis and Leonard Davis on the market as well there were better options. McGlynn proved to be better than Satele at center in 2013 but all in all wasn’t the best move Grigson made. I’m not even going to waste the time on the Satele signing. Justice was traded for and turned out to be an okay option but struggled with injuries.
Bringing in Brandon McKinney was a solid pick up as there wasn’t really another good option other than Pat Sims or Paul Soliai. They picked up Josh Chapman in the draft but they knew he would be at least a year before he would play coming off knee surgery.
Butler was picked up during the season and paid dividends almost immediately. Vontae Davis was traded to the Colts from Miami for a 2nd round pick. I think we all know we got the better of that deal. And the re-signing of Reggie Wayne proved to be a very smart move as he was Luck’s security blanket in his rookie year.
2012 FA Signing Grade: C
2013 FA Signings
Colts Signined or Traded For: Who Else Was Available:
Gosder Cherilus Jermon Bushrod, Phil Loadholt
Donald Thomas Willie Colon, Louis Vasquez
Greg Toler Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie
Eric Walden Connor Barwin, Shawn Phillips
Ricky Jean-Francois Tommy Kelly, Arthur Jones
Darrius Heyward-Bey Jerome Simpson, Emmanuel Sanders
Let’s start with the obvious. Grigson overpaid, or over traded, for Trent Richardson. He had a solid rookie campaign and if you think about the reasoning behind the trade it makes sense. However, he probably could have given up a 2nd and a 3rd or two 2nd round picks and still got him from Cleveland.
Cherilus and Thomas were both solid signings. Thomas went down and forced a rookie to step in right away in Hugh Thornton. Cherilus was very solid and continues to be at the right tackle position. The only person I would replace Cherilus with then is possible Phil Loadholt, but that would have cost a lot more money that Grigson was prepared to spend at that position. Thomas was someone I was glad they signed but this free agent class had a few other guys that would have been better options. More expensive options but better nonetheless. Louis Vasquez or Andy Levitre are obvious choices but even Willie Colon would have been a better pick up in my mind. All in all, for the money spent they got one solid guy and one that showed he was going to be a mainstay at LG but devastating season-ending injuries proved he wasn’t.
Greg Toler and Erik Walden are possibly the sole reasons I wanted to get this article done. Okay, throw Trent in there as well. Obviously there were better options for both guys. DRC, Terence Newman, or even keeping Jerraud Powers would have been better moves than signing Toler. Toler came with injury concerns and Powers was coming off an injury. DRC would have cost a pretty penny but paired with Davis, the Colts would have had an elite secondary with Bethea and Landry. Walden was the biggest miss on FA signings during this season. Shaun Phillips and James Harrison were available and would have been good fits here in Indy and also would have been able to pair up with Mathis really well.
Guys like RJF, Landry and Bradshaw made sense at the time. Landry was coming off a Pro Bowl season, RJF was a major contributor in San Francisco and Bradshaw was…well Ahmad Bradshaw. We won’t waste time on DHB. That was a low risk, high reward situation that failed.
All in all, the 2013 free agent draft class wasn’t full of blockbuster signings and obviously some of them are still considered busted signings to this day.
2013 FA Signing Grade: C-
2014 FA Signings: B
I will be the guy to say that Grigson has swung and missed on a few guys in his young GM career. The Richardson trade and signing guys like Landry and McKinney haven’t or won’t pan out. I won’t put DHB completely on him. The team took a chance and it didn’t work out. That’s fine…high reward low risk signings don’t always work. I said this to start this article and I was finish it with the same things. The draft is a crap shoot just as much as free agency is and Grigson hasn’t done a bad job unless you are always going to compare the 2012 draft class to every one after. If you are then you don’t like anything that Grigson has done nor will you. I have to say this in closing. Ryan Grigson has put the three teams together in the last three seasons. 11-5 for the past two and on a 5 game winning streak this season seems to be like someone knows what they are doing.